Grocery and retail · Data story

Uncommitted: five shifts in how people shop for groceries

Brandon Hillier · 7 min read

In January I hosted a Progressive Grocer webinar with Mark Kotcher, SVP of Sales and Business Development at Save A Lot, on why fewer shoppers stick to one store. Here's what the data showed, and what I'd do about it.

90%+

of grocery shoppers visit any single store banner fewer than four times a month.

Source: Upside's Consumer Spend Report, built on more than 10 billion transactions and surveys of over 11,000 consumers and retailers.

Watch the full conversation

Uncommitment and the Wallet Divide: How Shopping Behavior Is Changing

Hosted by Progressive Grocer, with Mark Kotcher of Save A Lot. On demand on Upside's site.

Watch on demand

Five shifts, in five numbers

72%

of the average grocer's revenue comes from uncommitted customers

1. The uncommitted shopper is now the majority

Shoppers who split their trips across banners now drive most of the business. Price pressure gives them a reason to shop around, and apps and price comparison make it easy. Mark's first step was empathy: understand why shoppers move before trying to change it.

$75K

household income, the line where spending splits

2. One label, two very different shoppers

Households above about $75,000 say they're spending more. Households below it are cutting back on grocery, fuel and restaurants. Higher earners compare prices too, so uncommitted behavior runs across the whole income range, just for different reasons.

3x

as many stores shopped by frequent online grocery buyers

3. The tools built for loyalty make leaving easier

Loyalty apps, online ordering and price transparency make a store easier to reach. They make every other store easier to reach too. Frequent online grocery shoppers buy from three times as many stores as in-store-only shoppers, and the average shopper now visits more than three banners a month.

30 pts

between saying rewards matter and using a program regularly

4. Joining a program isn't changing behavior

Nearly half of the retailers surveyed said loyalty participation and loyal behavior weren't improving. Save A Lot's answer leans on the store itself: more than 160 locally owned stores built for a quick trip, with a butcher in every one.

84%

revenue upside from one more monthly trip per uncommitted shopper

5. Segments are too blunt for this shopper

Broad segments can't explain why one household picks your store on Tuesday and a competitor on Saturday. Winning the next trip takes insight into what moves each shopper. The prize is large: Upside's data puts one more visit a month from each uncommitted shopper at an 84% lift in revenue.

“That's not loyalty, it's discipline.”
Mark Kotcher, Save A Lot, on a focus-group shopper who checks prices online before choosing where to go

What this means if you sell retail or commerce media

Sell the next trip

A grocer with this shopper base doesn't need more reach. It needs the uncommitted shopper's next visit. Frame every program around trips won, not impressions served.

Count only the new trips

If a shopper would have come anyway, the retailer paid for nothing. Hold out a control group and report the visits that wouldn't have happened without you.

Personal beats blanket

An offer matched to one household's habits wins the trip at a lower cost than a store-wide discount, and it protects the margin the grocer is fighting for.

Working on the uncommitted shopper problem? I'd welcome 20 minutes to compare notes.

Figures are from Upside's Consumer Spend Report, as shared in the webinar and in my recap on Upside's blog.

Next post: How I use AI as a sales leader

Email me LinkedIn