← Brandon Hillier
bh

Offers vs. ads: where performance commerce fits in the CPG budget

Brands now buy media, shopper marketing and offers from the same retailers, often from different budgets. Offers that drive a measurable sale earn a bigger share, but only when they're sold as growth, not as a discount.

Where offers go wrong

1

Paying loyal shoppers. Discounts for people who'd buy anyway prove nothing.

2

Sold as trade spend. Offers parked in the promo budget compete on price, not on growth.

3

Measured on redemptions. Redemption counts say nothing about the new buyers a brand wants.

What winning platforms do

1

Target new and lapsed buyers. Spend goes where the sale wouldn't happen on its own.

2

Pay for the sale. A cost per verified purchase is the easiest buy a CFO approves.

3

Sell across budgets. One package that brand, shopper and trade teams all win with.

4

Show profit, not volume. Margin for the retailer, new units for the brand.

If I owned this: my first 90 days

Days 1–30

Find the budget. Map how the top 10 CPG partners split media, shopper and trade dollars.

Days 31–60

Prove the lift. Run new-buyer offer tests with 5 brands, measured against a holdout.

Days 61–90

Package it. Turn the wins into a cross-budget offer the sales team can repeat.

Why me: nearly 20 years leading ad tech and commerce sales

$400M+

GMV from retailer partnerships at Upside, plus $33M in retailer profit lift

100+

Brand partners signed at Darkstore, driving 60% of the marketplace's GMV

$0 → $18M

GIPHY's ad sales org in year one, plus its first holdco deal (Publicis)

If performance commerce is on your 2027 plan, I'd welcome 20 minutes to compare notes.

Brandon Hillier

bhillier3@gmail.com · linkedin.com/in/brandonhillier