CPG buyers have stopped renewing retail media on faith. The easy trade and shopper dollars are spent, and the next wave comes from national budgets with a CFO attached. Every renewal now asks one question: what sales would we have lost without this spend?
1
Attribution dressed up as lift. Last-touch ROAS credits ads for shoppers who'd buy anyway, and brand finance knows it.
2
Tests designed after the fact. Holdouts bolted on at renewal are too small and too late, and the brand never trusts them.
3
Sellers who can't speak finance. Reps pitch reach. The buyer's boss asks about incremental margin, and the deal stalls.
1
Agree on the test upfront. Holdout size, read window and success metric go into the IO.
2
Report incremental sales and margin. Lead with net-new buyers, not ROAS.
3
Sell the joint business plan. Turn every renewal into a planning meeting.
4
Train sellers to talk to finance. Everyone can explain a holdout in two minutes.
Days 1–30
Listen and pick. Join renewals with the top 10 CPG accounts. Find 3 blocked by measurement and 2 ready to grow.
Days 31–60
Run the play. Co-design holdouts with those 5 brands before their next flight. Ship a readout finance can use as is.
Days 61–90
Make it repeatable. Make the readout the standard renewal deck, and put test design into every joint business plan.
$400M+
GMV from retailer partnerships at Upside, plus $33M in retailer profit lift
$0 → $18M
GIPHY's ad sales org in year one, plus its first holdco deal (Publicis)
$30M+
Holdco deals with IPG and Dentsu at Kargo, as its #1 new‑business seller
If proving lift is on your team's 2027 list, I'd welcome 20 minutes to compare notes.
Brandon Hillier